Healthy soils: why carbon alone is not enough as a measure

Soil quality has several dimensions

Fertile soil consists of more than a particular amount of humus. Its pore structure, chemical properties and biological processes work together. A high nutrient content, for example, is of little use if severe compaction leaves roots with scarcely any suitable space. An unprotected surface can likewise be eroded by water or wind. The FAO therefore links sustainable soil management to maintaining a range of soil functions. These include productive use, water regulation and the protection of organic carbon stocks. In practice, a diagnosis is needed first: what limitation is actually present, at what depth and under what conditions? Visible symptoms such as poor plant growth can have different causes. Blanket additional fertilisation or cultivation therefore does not necessarily address the problem and, under unfavourable circumstances, can even exacerbate existing pressures.

Compaction is better prevented than repaired

Heavy loads can compress soil pores, impairing water movement and root penetration. Driving over soil at unsuitable moisture levels can be particularly critical. The FAO therefore provides materials on preventing and treating soil compaction. One important approach is to match loads to soil conditions and bearing capacity. Loosening measures, by contrast, are not automatically effective in the long term: if loads are subsequently applied again under similar conditions, the problem can recur. A distinction must also be made between compaction near the surface and deeper down. Organic matter and suitable root penetration can support structural development, but do not replace careful planning of vehicle movements. The same basic principle applies to construction sites: soil should not be treated as living material only once all work is complete. Its protection begins with storage, traffic routes and the handling of wet areas throughout the construction phase.

Building up carbon takes time and monitoring

The FAO’s RECSOIL initiative promotes practices intended to increase or maintain soil organic carbon. Such measures can also support soil functions, but their effects depend on the site. Initial stocks, climate, soil type and management influence the outcome. Moreover, stored carbon is not permanently protected against subsequent losses. A change in use or unfavourable conditions can release some of it again. Robust conclusions therefore require repeated investigations using comparable methods. Individual samples or short-term fluctuations are not enough to establish a long-term trend reliably. The practical value of good soil management should also not be judged solely in terms of a possible climate credit. Less erosion, better root penetration and a more stable water balance can be goals in their own right, even if the additional carbon build-up remains small or can only be demonstrated over a longer period.

Keep exploring

• Agrivoltaics: two harvests from one area?
• The climate-friendly building material may be the component already there
• Bio-based building materials: renewable origins are only the beginning