How light splits water: the chemistry of photosystem II

Several subprocesses rather than a single trick with light

Photosynthetic organisms capture light energy using pigments and transfer it to reaction centres. In photosystem II, this energy enables charge separation. The resulting electron deficit is ultimately replenished by electrons from water. Water oxidation produces molecular oxygen and protons. This requires several electron transfers to be coordinated; a single absorbed quantum of light does not accomplish the entire chemical transformation. A metal cluster containing manganese and calcium plays a central role in the oxygen-evolving complex. Subsequent photosynthetic processes use the energy and reducing power gained in further steps. The familiar overall equation is therefore useful as a balance sheet, but inadequate as a mechanistic description. It shows neither the spatial organisation of the proteins nor the sequence of intermediate states that make a controlled reaction possible in the first place.

Intermediate states are inferred using several methods

The crucial chemical states are short-lived, and not all of them can be observed directly and fully with a single method. Structural studies reveal spatial arrangements, while spectroscopic techniques provide information about electronic states and local environments. Quantum chemical calculations help compare possible structures and reaction pathways with such measurement data. The research group at the Max Planck Institute for Coal Research explicitly describes this connection between spectroscopy and theoretical models. A calculated energetically favourable pathway is not, however, experimental proof that this exact pathway is followed in the protein. Conversely, a spectrum may admit several explanations. A model becomes particularly informative when it explains different measurements simultaneously and predicts new, testable differences between competing mechanisms. Research here therefore often involves a gradual narrowing of possibilities rather than a single definitive picture of the entire reaction.

Artificial imitation need not faithfully reproduce nature

Natural water oxidation provides inspiration for artificial systems intended to store light energy chemically. This does not necessarily mean reconstructing the entire biological protein. Synthetic catalysts can perform individual functions using other materials. What matters then is not just demonstrating the basic reaction, but also energy requirements, durability and integration into a complete system. A catalyst that evolves oxygen under special laboratory conditions is not yet a finished plant for producing a storable energy carrier. The central role of photosystem II and the fact that the released oxygen comes from water are established. Details of the reaction sequence and their technological application remain subjects of research. Natural photosynthesis is therefore both well-understood fundamental knowledge and a field with unresolved detailed questions — without these two levels having to contradict one another or justify spectacular promises of applications.

Keep exploring

• Diving measurement buoys: how Argo observes the ocean from within
• More than temperature: how measurement buoys capture biogeochemical processes
• Food from chemical energy: how deep-sea communities function